A new season of BBL is here, and it’s time to take a look at our 24 new teams. Here I’ll go through each team and produce a rough ranking, based on basic observation and analysis of their batting and fielding lineups and extra factors.
1) Green Monsters
Home field: Cement Gardens
Coach: Yurya (7.5-season (9.5-team) veteran, 85-71 lifetime record, 3 division titles, 1 wildcard title, 2 LDS titles)
Yurya’s a long way from his glory days now, and has fallen short with other promising teams in the past, but this might finally be the season where we see his return to glory. The Monsters are especially characterized by a strong defense; the outfield is a little suspect, but is made up for by a stellar infield anchored by Derek Jeter himself at shortstop, and low-power hitters in particular will have trouble getting much done against it. This team also has a solid offense, with a lot of players that are decent but not amazing in both hitting and running. There’s no elite sluggers or super speedsters in this group, but there’s no total liabilities either, and this particular build should work very well indeed at Cement Gardens; most if not all of this team’s losses will likely come on the road. Overall this is one of the best all-around builds in the NL, with a field it was built for and a coach with the experience to make that lineup produce. Let’s see if they can accomplish in practice what they seem capable of in theory.
2) Minnesota Twins
Home field: Steele Stadium
Coach: Toast (2-season veteran, 16-13 lifetime record)
Toast took a look at his home field of Steele Stadium and decided to go almost all-in based on that, picking a team that ended up having the highest average power rating in the entire league! Only two players on the Twins have power ratings of lower than 80, and this team will be able to produce deep drives on the regular – deep drives that will be even more effective at their home field. And somehow, despite having zero fast players, the Twins also don’t feel crippled by a lack of speed, all the solid bats and the lack of cripplingly slow players making up for it. The defense isn’t amazing – the outfield could prove a bit of an issue in road games, and the overall lack of speed might make a critical difference against faster teams – but it’s still a solid one on the whole that sets Toast up to potentially have a great season. The only concern here is when the coach goes cold – this team’s success will rely on consistently hitting the ball well, and if they start to have more trouble doing that, their stocks will start to plummet. But if Toast can stay nice and hot and crispy all season long, this team will be quite the sensation.
3) Crazy Yankees
Home field: Dubois Diamond
Coach: Crazyei8hts (8-season (10.5-team) veteran, 112-72 lifetime record, 4 division titles, 3 wildcard titles, 7 LDS titles, 3 LCS titles, 1 WS title)
Crazy is back at it again, ready to put forward another strong season. This team is actually a bit of an anomaly for him, heavy on neither strong bats nor strong arms, but it nevertheless has a good offense that he’ll likely be able to score high with as usual. The several slow players on the team are a bit of a concern, but the bats they boast help to alleviate that concern, and there’s enough fast players that I think this is, on the whole, a well-balanced offense that should be capable of good output, especially with Crazy able to ensure those bats work well. The biggest issue for this team is defense – there’s an overall lack of arm strength that is going to limit its effectiveness, and in particular the infield consisting of three not-great arms and a slow shortstop could prove to be a significant issue, especially in road games where Marky Dubois goes unboosted. Placing Donald Vogel at catcher and Todd Helton at short, rather than the other way around, seems to me like a mistake the Yankees might pay dearly for. Still, suspect though the defense might be, Crazyei8hts with this offense is going to ensure that it takes a major effort from other teams to beat him regardless.
4) Humongous Giants
Home field: The Paveway
Coach: Itaniium (BBL rookie)
Itaniium originally drafted a more offense-heavy team before undergoing a major roster overhaul near the trade deadline. While it didn’t make his team an amazing one, it did make it a solid one overall that has plenty of room to see success in this season. The defense is short on amazing players, especially with Ichiro stuck behind the plate, but it has a lot of solid players and very little in the way of holes. The aforementioned roster swaps also left the Giants without their top power hitters, but every player on the team is still decent with a bat, and there’s enough speed on the team that this lineup can still work, especially at their home field of The Paveway where this style of offense should be more effective. Ultimately this isn’t the most stacked team in the league, but it’s one that can get things done, and I think Itaniium has the potential to go far with them.
5) Chicago Brewers
Home field: Tin Can Alley
Coach: SilverBullet102 (2-season veteran, 1-27 lifetime record)
Silver is a real trooper for sticking with the league after two seasons as rough as he’s had, but things might be about to get better for him. Not only does he finally have a fix for SCUMM’s buggy hitting that’s been plaguing him the last two seasons, but he also has drafted himself a stacked offense for a field where they should thrive. This offense bears definite similarity to last season’s successful Melonheads lineup, full of solid power hitters and playing at Tin Can Alley where each and every hitter will be able to hit balls off the wall to get on base easily. The team’s slightly on the slow side, but not so much so that they won’t be able to produce runs, especially given that only three hitters have power ratings below 80, and overall this should be a fun offense to use. Now, there is a downside – this team’s defense isn’t great. It’s not terrible, but a lot of the fielders fall under the banner of “serviceable but not top-notch”, and some regions of the field look like they might be particularly vulnerable. It’s also not clear just how well this offense will perform on the road, and just because Silver has a SCUMM fix doesn’t mean he’ll suddenly become a top-tier player. But on the whole, things are looking bright for the Brewers, and this could easily be Silver’s breakout season.
6) Mighty Athletics
Home field: Playground Commons
Coach: arcothunder (BBL rookie)
In a league where I was skeptical about some aspect of most of these teams – whether the offense or the defense – the A’s rise up by being solid in both aspects. They don’t have any huge assets on offense except for Babe Ruth’s super home run bat, but they have a healthy amount of both power and speed all the way down their lineup and this should be a serviceable offense. Defense is where I like them more, as I think they have one of the more threatening outfields in the league to go with a mostly strong infield. Piazza at first might be what makes or breaks this team, but if both he and Hudson post-pitching can do well, I think this will be a pretty tough defense to break. The biggest question right now for the A’s is their coach, as Arco struggled in the June Joust tournament, but I’m not sure what exactly the cause of his struggles was, that was only three games, and it’s perfectly feasible that he rebounds for this season and puts out a solid effort with this solid squad.
7) Seattle Fishes
Home field: Eckman Acres
Coach: elchrisblanco (3.5-season veteran, 34-27 lifetime record, 1 division title, 1 wildcard title, 1 LDS title)
Chris just came off of a successful Season 8 where having one of the top defenses in the league allowed him to get by with an unimpressive offense, so it’s interesting to see him here with a defense that I’m not so big on. The outfield is solid but not great, while the infield has a lot of slower players with not-great arms. Sarah Maxwell ought to help out a lot with that, but if she loses too much stamina and effectiveness in her starting pitching stint, things could get ugly for this defense. To counter this, the Fishes’ offense is solid, but not great. Brad Radke and Trent Sizemore could prove tough to get much done with, and while there’s decent speed and decent hitting on this team, there’s a lack of really great talent on offense, nothing that I think will really give the Fishes an edge. It’s true that they’ll look better at home when Kimmy Eckman’s boost is applied, but I dn’t know that that will be enough. Ultimately, the biggest point in this team’s favor is their coach. Chris has proven his acumen and been successful in recent seasons, and he just might be able to lead this squad to another good performance.
8) St. Louis Cardinals
Home field: Casa de Pablo
Coach: Wizard (4-season veteran, 36-29 lifetime record, 2 wildcard titles, 1 LDS title)
Wizard, what are you doing? The biggest thing that stands out to me looking at this team is the lack of speed, with only a single fast player and five players that are below average in speed – and this team plays at Casa de Pablo! That means they will be going nowhere fast, and this could be a long season indeed for the Wiz. He attempted to make up for this by drafting a lot of power bats to be one of the hardest-hitting teams in the league, but Big Bats at Sandy Flats has historically been a poor-performing strategy, and Casa’s even harder to hit the ball out of. And rather than drafting a ton of top-tier power bats, the Cards went for a low floor, with a lot of solid bats in the 60s and 70s but only a few super sluggers. I doubt that will be enough to make up for their slow speed on the basepaths, and this offense might have a rough time of it. The Cards’ defense is at least solid, with no huge holes and Jeter clone Marilyn McDonnel in play, and with a lot of strong arms on the field, nobody else is going to enjoy facing the Cards at the Casa. Wizard is also a coach with proven tenacity who has always been in the running for the playoffs. But he’s still going to face an uphill battle this season.
9) Blue Marlins
Home field: Parks Department #2
Coach: shrewsbury91 (3-season veteran, 19-23 lifetime record)
The Marlins have another offense that I’m none too fond of here, with a similar problem to the Cards’ in a glut of slower players and a lack of big power bats. They do at least have super-speedster Stuart Sullivan to help out, and all of those solid but not amazing bats should do well at their home field of Parks, but they might struggle more away from home, and in any case Erin Harris and Ryan VanderHoek are likely to prove significant problems for the Marlins’ rallies. The good news for the Marlins is they have a good tight infield, which should cause its share of problems for weaker opposing hitters, and the plan for Mr. Clanky to go behind the plate after five runs. The bad news is that Clanky could come back on the mound later on to mess all this up, and the Marlins’ outfield is unimpressive. Overall, the Marlins aren’t a terrible team, but I do think they’re underpowered and have the potential for some disastrous results.
10) Super-Duper Melonheads
Home field: Parks Department #2
Coach: Eauxps I. Fourgott (6-season (9-team) veteran, 52-74 lifetime record, 2 division titles, 1 LDS title)
On the one hand, I like the offense that I’ve drafted myself here; I think it strikes a good balance between power and speed and has no glaring holes in it. On the other hand, I think it’s also the sort of offense that I might struggle to harness considerably, and while there will likely be some big games from this Melonheads squad, there will also likely be some big duds from them. On paper, I like my defense pretty well also, but the outfield is a potential weak point that might be suspect to fatigue later on, and between that and the not-so-glowing reviews I’ve heard of it, I get the suspicion that in practice it will probably get beat up on a lot, with the hitter’s field Parks not helping their case at all. Overall I don’t think this is going to be the worst iteration I’ve had of the Melonheads – but I don’t know that they’re set up for success in this landscape either.
11) Mighty Wombats
Home field: Steele Stadium
Coach: Marco (4-season veteran, 23-32 lifetime record)
There are a number of offenses in the NL that I’m skeptical about this season, but none so much as the Wombats’. They’re another team that went for a high floor in terms of batting power, and while that does mean they have no weak hitters, it also ended up meaning that they have an awful lot of average hitters – power ratings in the 50s and 60s that are solid, but not great. They have two stronger bats but no top-tier ones, and they don’t have the fast speed or favorable home field that would be needed for this array of bats to find success. Indeed, their home field of Steele Stadium will likely hurt them more than it helps, as their opponents might enjoy that short porch but almost no Wombats are positioned to take advantage of it. This is the sort of offense that requires long strings of good solid hits to enjoy success, and while that’s not impossible, it’s difficult to produce consistently, and I think they ultimately won’t do so well this season. Their defense is solid, but it’s not amazing, and ultimately I think this team’s fortunes will be decided by their offense – or lack thereof.
12) Super-Duper Diamondbacks
Home field: Scrapco Field
Coach: PepsiBoyTTV (BBL rookie)
Shortly before the trade deadline, PepsiBoy largely overhauled his team, gutting it of most of its best talent on defense in order to load it up with big hitters and runners. The result is an offense that should be dynamic, fun to use, and effective, with four different top tier power bats, two super speedsters, no really slow kids, and a couple of other useful players as well. But there are still weak points in the offense – Linda Potter and Tina Herrara might be difficult to fit in and get a lot accomplished with – and it’s unclear how a rookie like PepsiBoy will do with them, especially after he struggled in the June Joust tournament. Instead, I think the main story with this team, and the reason they fall to the back of the preseason power rankings, will be their defense, which in the wake of the big roster overhaul is looking like it will be one of the worst defenses in the league. They have Linda, who’s at first base. They have Tina, who’s behind the plate. They have Henri Deschenes, who will be the heart and soul of this defense from his position at short. And then they have six players with relatively weak arms, who will struggle to get the ball anywhere fast. This should be one of the easiest defenses in the league to put up big scores against, doubly so when playing at their home field at Scrapco, and if Henri gets too tired out and ineffective when he comes on to pitch, they’ll have nobody left to fall back on. We’ll see if Pepsi can harness the upsides of this team well enough to overcome this disadvantage, and it’s not unthinkable that the offense will win out. But here at the outset of the season, I do think their defense is the biggest weakness that any NL team has.
Predictions
NL East
4) Wombats. That lineup is a serious problem to me, and I don’t see any strengths on this team that can give them the edge.
3) Marlins. Their fate may be pretty similar to that of the Wombats, but I think this is a slightly better team that can squeeze out one or two more wins.
2) Giants. This is a solid all-around squad, and even if they don’t actually secure a playoff spot, they ought to be part of the race.
1) Brewers. I’m going to take the role of Silver’s cheerleader here during the preseason. There’s a lot of potential variance with this team, but they definitely has what it takes to make a playoff run, especially if their coach settles in within the first few weeks. We could see this happen.
NL Central
4) Diamondbacks. Ultimately I think the lack of defense on this team will dig too deep of a hole for their offense to climb out of, and they won’t be able to collect that many wins.
3) Fishes. I can’t give too much credit to this team just for having a good coach. They appear significantly weaker than their competition, and that may well result in Chris’s worst season in a while.
2) Athletics. A very solid all-around squad, but are they good enough to help a rookie coach reach the playoffs? Not via a division title at least, not in a division with Crazyei8hts.
1) Yankees. Crazy’s skill as a coach combined with a strong offense will propel him to yet another playoff berth.
NL West
4) Melonheads. It may be a rough season ahead for my team. I can’t predict success until I see a solid basis for it.
3) Cardinals. The Cards might have a rough season as well, but when in doubt, go with the better coach.
2) Twins. The Twins should have a good season and are my pick for NL Wild Card, but I think they’ll have enough off games for their tough competition to edge them out.
1) Monsters. I’ve been fooled by Yurya’s squads before, but this time. THIS time, I think we finally have his return to the playoffs after a five-season absence. This team is, simply put, very good.
As a bit of bonus content, briefly thought-out playoff predictions:
Division playoffs: Orioles over Devil Rays, Cubs over Pirates, Yankees over Twins, Monsters over Brewers
League championship series: Cubs over Orioles, Yankees over Monsters
World Series: Cubs over Yankees. Emery wins back-to-back titles.